Key Takeaways
- Construction cost inflation of 30-50% since 2019 means many properties are significantly underinsured—update replacement cost estimates annually.
- Conduct policy audits annually and after any significant property change (renovation, acquisition, major loss).
- Common audit findings include underinsured replacement cost, missing endorsements, and outdated lender mortgagee clauses.
- The cost of annual policy auditing is negligible compared to the cost of discovering a coverage gap during a major claim.
Insurance policies that were adequate at acquisition can become dangerously inadequate over time. Construction costs increase, property values change, new risks emerge, and policy terms may be modified at renewal. Regular policy auditing and adequacy testing ensures that coverage keeps pace with exposure.
Testing Coverage Adequacy
Coverage adequacy testing compares the current insurance program against the current risk profile. Property coverage: compare the insured replacement cost against current construction cost estimates (use Marshall & Swift or similar cost estimation tools). Construction costs have increased 30-50% in many markets since 2019—policies not updated may be significantly underinsured. Liability coverage: evaluate whether current limits are adequate given the property value, number of tenants, and local litigation environment. A $1M CGL limit may be insufficient in high-litigation jurisdictions where slip-and-fall verdicts routinely exceed $500,000. Loss of rents: verify that the loss of rents period (typically 12 months) is sufficient for the worst-case restoration timeline. Major fires in older buildings can take 18-24 months to restore.
The Policy Audit Process
A systematic policy audit should be conducted annually and whenever a significant change occurs (renovation, expansion, acquisition, or major loss). The audit checklist: (1) verify named insured matches the current ownership entity, (2) confirm the legal description and property address are correct, (3) review coverage limits against current replacement cost estimates, (4) verify all required endorsements are in place (sewer backup, ordinance or law, equipment breakdown, loss of rents), (5) check deductible levels against current risk tolerance and reserve levels, (6) confirm flood zone designation has not changed (FEMA map updates occur periodically), (7) review exclusions for any new items added at renewal, (8) verify lender requirements are met (mortgagee clause, minimum limits, COI distribution), and (9) compare premiums against market benchmarks and competitor quotes.
Common Audit Findings and Remediation
Common audit findings include: underinsured replacement cost (found in 40-60% of audits), missing or expired certificates from contractors and tenants, endorsements dropped at renewal without notice, lender mortgagee clause using an outdated name or address, and flood coverage not updated after FEMA map revision. Remediation involves: updating coverage limits to current replacement costs, obtaining updated certificates from all vendors and tenants, adding back any endorsements dropped at renewal, correcting the mortgagee clause, and adjusting flood coverage for any zone changes. The cost of remediation is almost always less than the cost of a coverage gap discovered during a claim.
Common Pitfalls
Never updating the insured replacement cost after acquisition
Risk: Construction cost inflation creates a growing coverage gap—a 40% increase in costs means a $2M building needs $2.8M in coverage
Update replacement cost estimates annually using construction cost indices and obtain an appraisal every 3 years
Assuming the policy renewed with the same terms and endorsements as the prior year
Risk: Carriers may drop endorsements, add exclusions, or change deductibles at renewal without prominent notice
Review every renewal policy page by page against the expiring policy to identify any changes in terms, endorsements, or exclusions
Best Practices Checklist
Sources
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Never updating the insured replacement cost after acquisition
Consequence: Construction cost inflation creates a growing coverage gap—a 40% increase in costs means a $2M building needs $2.8M in coverage
Correction: Update replacement cost estimates annually using construction cost indices and obtain an appraisal every 3 years
Assuming the policy renewed with the same terms and endorsements as the prior year
Consequence: Carriers may drop endorsements, add exclusions, or change deductibles at renewal without prominent notice
Correction: Review every renewal policy page by page against the expiring policy to identify any changes in terms, endorsements, or exclusions
"Insurance Compliance: Auditing, Liability Control & Specialized Coverage" is a Pro track
Upgrade to access all lessons in this track and the entire curriculum.
Immediate access to the rest of this content
1,746+ structured curriculum lessons
All 33+ real estate calculators
Metro-level data across 50+ regions
Test Your Knowledge
1.What is the purpose of an insurance policy audit?
2.How often should insurance adequacy be tested?
3.What is the most common audit finding for multifamily properties?